I just returned from a week in Playa del Carmen, Mexico. One of the reasons we opted for Playa was that the town was reputed to have good food. Every day, we had tacos of some sort for lunch -- often from a small little stand where the grill is right in front -- those were the best! When we weren't eating tacos, we tried all sorts of places: touristy, off the beaten path, fancy, hole in the wall. Some were hits, some were misses, here are the standouts (for one reason or another!).
Yaxche
On our first night, we went to Yaxche since it offered authentic Mayan cuisine. The food wasn't so hot and like so many places in Playa, the restaurant was next to a construction site (Playa seems to be in a constant state of building and rebuilding). I couldn't decide whether or not my bright green drink looked more like an ecto-cooler or a vegan health drink -- it tasted OK, though. For the rest of the meal, the panuchos (a type of taco) were excellent and Glenn's black stuffed turkey was nothing else if not memorable because of the color.
John Gray's Place
This is restaurant run by a former Ritz-Carlton chef offers solid "New American" cuisine. Service was friendly and the bacon-spinach salad was amazing. One knock against them: the green beans that came with my duck were extremely overcooked. Pricey, but very good food.
Senor Tacombi
It's tacos and smoothies. Served from a converted VW bus! Yeah, it's a gimmick, but it sure was fun. The standouts here were the mango smoothies and the fried fish tacos with red cabbage.
Sur
Right on the main pedestrian strip, sits Sur. An Argentinian steakhouse, Sur boasts open air dining from the second story and fantastic people watching. Hands down, this was our favorite place -- service, ambiance, food, experience. It
is pricey, though. We shared meat empanadas to start. Glenn had rib-eye and I had grilled jumbo prawns (I had to remove the heads myself!)
Il Pescatore
Off the beaten path, this small Italian restaurant is run by a Roman hippie who chain-smokes in the restaurant and makes some amazing pasta. On a busier street, the ambiance wasn't perfect, but the food more than makes up for it and prices were very reasonable. We shared gnocchi with black truffle and some amazing fettuccine with bolognese sauce. And it was almost as good as Delfino's in Rozzie.